Doing Your Own JKD Thing

By Cass Magda
 
JKD has its own identity and follows a design with a purpose. It is a system. A JKD man's movement is definitely different and distinguishable from other martial arts such as Thai kickboxing, wing chun, or karate. The physical structure of JKD fits together in a certain way which defines its identity as JKD. If we add too much to this design, it could become a burden, the different parts not really working with each other. That's why the idea of simply putting together the "best of the martial arts" is not what JKD is about. We cannot take the best parts of certain cars and put them together hoping they will work well, because they are not designed to fit together. Putting together separate techniques from different arts so they flow, is in reality difficult because the structures of these arts are so different from each other. Flowing in a flight results from having a system that has become internalized and organic. One does not have to change structures or theories or even think about techniques - one just fights.
 
Bruce Lee used boxing, wing chun, and fencing as the main seminal elements of JKD. When we see JKD in action, we don't see any sign of fencing techniques! One the various theories of fencing are applied such as broken rhythm and the five ways of attack. In JKD we see a dynamic version of trapping hands that sort of resembles wing chun - but not the postures, stances, footwork, or body movement. The structure of wing chun is not there. The footwork and evasive body movement resembles that of a boxer but the stance is wider for kicking. The infighting, at times, is very much like boxing but the tactics of getting in are completely different. The structure of the classical boxer is not there.
 
Changing the design by absorbing the ideas and techniques from other martial arts into the JKD structure may or may no be OK. If the added techniques and concepts of the other martial arts changes the structure of JKD, then how can JKD fulfill its purpose and design? Is it still JKD? A speedboat, if loaded up with cargo, may be able to carry that cargo successfully--but is it still a speedboat following its original design and purpose, or is it now a cargo boat hauling a large load slowly? Slow and sure is not the purpose of a speedboat. It is not designed to carry a lot of cargo.
 
If we use this analogy for JKD then we see the obvious parallels. If we stray form the cornerstones of simplicity and directness and pile on too many techniques, theories, and strategies from other martial arts, then we have changed the essential nature of what we are doing into something else. We are no longer following the original design and purpose of JKD, so we can't call it JKD any more.
 
In the spirit of the philosophy of JKD, can we say we're doing our own thing now--our own JKD? This may be going too far. We need to be careful. If we added the theories and techniques from Kali stick-fighting and French savate into our judo structure, I don't think what we'd have could be called judo anymore. The judo structure would have to change. Would you now say you are doing your own judo? I don't think so. It is the same with JKD. The structure of JKD must be there to call it JKD.

4 Types of Martial Arts- What Should I Choose?

There are lots of styles and disciplines to choose from when it comes to martial art. However, you need to remember the fact no one martial art is better than the other and the only right martial art is the one that you will be happy pursuing....

Why Martial Arts Is More Than Just Kicking

  Martial arts was initially seen as combative and puzzling. It was mostly learned and practiced by adults and was chiefly about self-defense. Martial arts has ever since grown from that stage of tiny dirty schools to schools teaching...

Fencing without a foil?

Bruce Lee often called his art of Jeet Kune Do, fencing without a foil.  In this entry we will be discussing what he meant by that statement.   If you take a look at fencing and Jeet Kune Do, you will not a few similarities.  One of...

Finding a Little Bruce Lee in All of Us

A slew of Bruce Lee types, embracing both men and women, could soon be making their way through the streets of New York--but with an added physical dimension; expertise in rough, tough and often savage street fighting.  In brief, those bad...

Getting To The Roots of JKD

By Cass Magda   In the Tao of JKD Bruce Lee said, "I hope that martial artists are more interested in the root of martial arts and not the different decorative branches, flowers or leaves. It is futile to argue as to which single leaf,...

Jeet Kune Do: The Way of The "Stopping Fist"

Jeet Kune Do is training and discipline toward the ultimate reality in combat. The ultimate reality is returning to one's primary freedom, which is simple, direct, and nonclassical.  A good Jeet Kune Do man does not oppose force or give way...

Jeet Kune Do's Five Ways Of Attack

1. SDA (Single Direct Attack) A direct attack is composed of a single movement. The objective is to go to the target by the most direct route. Although it is the simplest of the attacks, it is the hardest to complete successfully because the speed...